Arc Troopers Vs Commandos
This file contains additional information, probably added from the digital camera or scanner used to create or digitize it.If the file has been modified from its original state, some details may not fully reflect the modified file. Hd1duration05:42publishedMay 14, 2017descriptionIt's a hard one.FOLLOW ME ON TWITCH:JOIN US ON INSTAGRAM:JOIN US ON DISCORD:COPYRIGHT FREE MUSIC:BATTLEFRONT BASE:Lost Frontier by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license Source:Artist:nametypecategoryKeywordsindustryratingagegateagerequired0provideryoutubelanguagesubtitlegenresactorstargetcountryseriesseasonepisodecharactersresolutionaspectratio1.7777778expirationdateregionalrestrictionstitleWho were the more Skilled? - ARC Troopers vs Clone Commandoscanembed1.
As a result, the GAR pits four ARC Troopers versus four Clone Commandos in a fight to the death. One the ARC side consists of Alpha-77 'Fordo', Alpha-17 'Alpha', Null-11 'Ordo' and Alpha-66 'Muzzle'. They are armed with their standard Westar-M5s with Fordo opting instead to use his two DC-17 pistols along with their ARC Armor.
I'm not exactly sure what ARCs specialize in so I'l do a few different scenerios. 1st scenario: A governor is being held hostage in the Endor base. Which team will be more succsful in rescuing him. 2nd scenario: 25 enemy targets (terrorist armed with basic AK47s) are in the bottom of the grand canyon. Which team will succeed (if any) in killing all 25 enemies in the fastest time. The team will start in the bottom of the grand canyon, 200 ft.
Away from the terrorist. Terrorist don't know that the teams are there. The playing field is one of those big chasm alleys in the grand canyon. 3rd scenario: Both navy seals and ARCs are versing each other in a jungle. Fight to the death 4th scenario: Both navy seals and ARCs are versing each other in a open arena with minimal barrels, and such for cover.
Standard weapons and gear. For the 1st and 2nd scenarios, the arcs and seals take the challenges individually. It is a 2 man team for each.
@k4tzm4n said: ' @comicdude23: How? ARC troopers are the special ops of the friggin Star Wars universe. ' Each Navy Seal is different, ARC Troopers, not so much. And it depends on the sitatuation, but for the majority of the time, I'm rolling with the Seals.
Situation 1 - Navy Seals would most likely reach the Govenor first, their more tactical and have better camo. Situation 2 - Navy Seals, due to Grenades.
Situation 3 - Navy Seals win, they have better camo and can adapt to the jungle, the ARC Troopers are wearing shiny white, they can easily be tagged. Situation 4 - In an all out battle, Trooper have the better tech. ARC TROOPERS. For those who are saying Navy Seals without knowing who ARC troopers are just stop right there.
ARC troopers have been more genetically enhanced than standard clone troopers and they have been personally trained by Jango Fett himself. They have top notch weapons, skills, are a good deal of intelligence for a clone. ARC troopers have stood up to Durge and Grievous. And one was even able to hurt Durge (the favored ARC Captain Fordo) shown in k4tsm2n's video (the red one).
Despite how cool Navy Seals are none of them would be able to that. ARC troopers win this. @LogicandDebate said: ' @k4tzm4n: Based off of the video, they seem to have impressive tech, but they don't come across as that stealthy. 'ARC troopers are troopers that go all out. @k4tzm4n said: ' @LogicandDebate.The mission didn't really call for stealth.
I'm more than positive they've been trained in stealth operations. To top if off, they have tech allowing them to see further and through walls. It's a stomp.
'You would think they would. But the Clone Commandos are the ones who do stealth missions. But the Null-ARC troopers (they were the first batch of ARC troopers that failed) have served beside Clone Commandos. But yes ARC troopers stomp without a doubt.
Just to clarify: ARCs are exactly what their name implies: Advanced Reconnaissance Commandos. They differ from Clone Commandos. They often work alone, in pairs, or with the aid of other types of units. They are often put in leadership positions (like Commander Cody).
Commandos work in squads of four to achieve their goals. SEALs work more as a team, so they are closer in similarity to Commandos than ARCs. @k4tzm4n said: ' Much respect for the training Seals go through, but the ARC troopers have the advantages of superior genetics (Friggin' Fett clones), and a HUGE advantage in technology, likely giving them even more tactical advantages.
@JediXMan said: ' ARCs. Just to clarify: ARCs are exactly what their name implies: Advanced Reconnaissance Commandos. They differ from Clone Commandos. They often work alone, in pairs, or with the aid of other types of units.
They are often put in leadership positions (like Commander Cody). Commandos work in squads of four to achieve their goals. SEALs work more as a team, so they are closer in similarity to Commandos than ARCs. @k4tzm4n said: ' Much respect for the training Seals go through, but the ARC troopers have the advantages of superior genetics (Friggin' Fett clones), and a HUGE advantage in technology, likely giving them even more tactical advantages. 'I don't believe Commander Cody is an ARC. I think he just got ARC training.
But I agree nonetheless. Who would win in the first two situations depends on a serious number of factors; firstly the equipment of the team, secondly who the opponents are in the bunker, thirdly whether or not the Arc troopers have been informed and taught about the soldiers they are facing in the canyon.First scenario, if they are facing battledroids both teams would probably succeed, however the Arc troopers would finish the mission in about half the time the Seals would because of two reasons: 1 the Arcs know these enemies and have superior knowledge of the battle strategies the droids will employ.
2 droid armour is designed to deflect blaster fire and is made of a flexible metal, bullets would probably dent it rather badly but allow the droid to function even when seriously damaged, however blasters (firing plasma bolts) melt their internals and ionise their circuitboards thus damaging the electronic chips which drive them.If they are facing humans or equivalent 'wets' then the seals would give the Arcs a run for their money but i would still err on the side of the Arcs in this case.Second scenario, the results of this vary greatly depending on the gear of the team. Arcs could all be carrying reciprocating quad-blasters (miniguns) and rocket launchers which would tear anything to shreds in seconds, if they were armed with a standard DC15 or 17 then it would take them longer but it would still be accomplished with probably zero casualties.
If the seal team were armed with machineguns the effects would likely be the same. Zero casualties for both sides, indeterminate time period.If there was no requirement for the team to survive then i would side with the Arcs, because they are indoctrinated to be semi-suicidal. They will not throw their lives away blindly but if they were required to they would. Seal teams i would expect to be a bit more hesitant about this, which frankly is good for them because we've all seen how blindly most clones follow orders.Third scenario, Arcs. No doubt about it. Camo wont do a thing for the Seals because as has been demonstrated in the above video they can quite literally see through walls, and they don't need thermal vision to do it either because those droids are IR invisible if you're facing Phase 2 troopers then their helmets have this as standard and don't need the binocs.
On the other side we have the Arcs. A couple of notes to be made here. Their armour is not bulletproof. It will deflect a bullet and is designed to be vapourised when hit by blasters. Read up Ablative armour if you want to know more. And their white pristine armour, it aint for show. It is matt white for a reason, and that is because if you have white armour you can paint it any colour of the rainbow, and often clones will wipe their armour in mud and dirt of a world to camouflage themselves.
The only reason you dont ever see them do it in the films is because all the battles we've seen them in involve them being deployed rapidly when they haven't had chance to apply this camo yet. The Arcs are also adept at hit and run, and because of their genetic alterations they can probably run faster than Seals. To wrap it up, the Seal's camo wouldn't work, the Arc's would assuming they had 2 to 3 minutes to spare before the fight, the Arc armour would be a minor bonus but not the gamechanger most people think it would be.
Arc Troopers Vs Commandos
The Arcs have more endurance and would win in a protracted fight. Also rifles, a DC15 has gas for 500 shots and an energy cell for 50.
Arc Troopers Vs Commandos Game
Each clone carries two additional gas canisters (which are non-explosive i might add) and a corresponding number of energy cells (also non-explosive, although they are acidic and you'll want to wash your hands if you get any of the fluid on you because it will start itching) And each shot will go straight through any helmet or armour the seals are wearing.The Seals are outmatched because of the superior technology and genetics of the ArcsFourth scenario, the Arcs would win, for the reasons above. Better weapons, better armour.
Camo plays less of a role here. The Arcs would however suffer far heavier casualties than they would in the jungle scenario.In all of the scenarios the Arcs would win by a larger margin if they are Alpha Arcs (second batch of soldiers ever made, these are the ones trained by Jango. Beta Arcs were trained by the Alpha Arcs that had survived to that point) or even Null Arcs (Arcs who are defective specifically because of their ruthlessness and unwillingness to follow orders except those from 'papa kal')If you have a choice between taking an Arc trooper or a Seal, take the one trained from birth.
He'll follow any order you give him.